Why Making Cancellation Difficult Is Becoming an Expensive Mistake

Subscriptions have become one of the most popular business models in the digital economy. Media, software, financial data, investment research, trading tools and premium banking features are all increasingly sold on a recurring basis. For businesses, subscriptions offer predictable revenue and an ongoing relationship with customers. For customers, they offer convenience, provided the terms are clear and leaving is as easy as joining.
That proviso is where many companies have run into trouble. Introductory offers that renew at much higher prices, renewal notices that are easy to miss and cancellation processes that require several pages, a phone call or a conversation with a retention agent have become common enough that regulators now treat them as a consumer protection priority. What once looked like clever retention tactics increasingly looks like legal risk.
A recent case shows how seriously authorities are taking the issue. The New York Attorney General’s Office announced Bloomberg’s $500,000 settlement over subscription friction for its consumer website subscriptions, alleging that the company failed to disclose automatic renewals and steep price increases clearly and made cancellation difficult. Some customers could sign up for $1.99 a month for three months before the price rose automatically to $39.99 a month. The settlement requires changes to disclosures, consent, renewal notices and the cancellation process, along with refunds for eligible customers. It concerns consumer subscriptions rather than Bloomberg’s professional terminal contracts.
The case is instructive because the underlying business practice was not unusual. Many publishers and digital services use low introductory prices that renew at standard rates. The issue was not that subscriptions renewed, but whether customers clearly understood what they were agreeing to and could leave easily. New York’s automatic renewal law requires businesses to disclose material terms, obtain affirmative consent and provide a cancellation mechanism that is as easy to use as the one through which the customer enrolled.
That last requirement is spreading. Several US states have similar rules, and regulators elsewhere have taken comparable positions. The UK’s Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act includes new rules for subscription contracts covering reminders, cooling-off rights and straightforward exit. Consumer protection authorities in the European Union have also coordinated action against misleading subscription practices. Businesses operating across borders face a growing patchwork of obligations that all point in the same direction.
Financial services firms should pay particular attention. Trading platforms, investment research services, premium bank accounts and financial data products often rely on recurring fees. Many already operate under conduct rules that require fair treatment of customers, such as the UK’s Consumer Duty, which explicitly addresses unreasonable barriers to switching or cancelling a product. A cancellation process that keeps customers paying for services they no longer want is difficult to reconcile with an obligation to deliver good outcomes.
There is also a commercial argument for change. Friction can inflate retention metrics in the short term, but continued billing does not necessarily mean a customer values the service. Customers who feel trapped are more likely to complain, dispute charges with their card issuer and warn others away. When they finally leave, they rarely return. Businesses that rely on friction to retain customers may be overstating the health of their subscriber base and underestimating the reputational damage it causes.
Good subscription design covers the full lifecycle. At sign-up, the renewal price, timing and frequency should be stated as clearly as the introductory offer, close to the point where the customer agrees. After purchase, a confirmation should restate the key terms. Before renewal, especially when the price is about to rise, customers should receive a timely reminder. And at any point, cancellation should be possible through the same channel the customer used to subscribe, without unnecessary steps.
Retention offers are not prohibited, and many customers appreciate being told about a cheaper plan or the option to pause. The difference lies in whether those offers inform a free choice or obstruct the exit. A single clear offer presented alongside a visible cancellation button respects the customer. Several pages of questions before cancellation becomes possible do not.
Measurement deserves a rethink as well. Companies that track how many customers attempt to cancel but fail to complete the process, how many contact support about unexpected renewals and how many dispute charges will get a more honest picture of customer satisfaction than headline retention rates alone. Those signals often reveal friction long before a regulator does.
The broader lesson for digital and financial businesses is that trust is part of the product. Clear pricing, honest renewal terms and easy cancellation may reduce some short-term revenue, but they build the kind of customer relationship that subscription businesses ultimately depend on. As regulators continue to act, companies that redesign their subscription journeys now will avoid both penalties and the slower damage that friction does to a brand.
